Y
yeti
Guest
Depending on the amp those two volume controls are worse that a pedal. Fender amps are the worst at this. Just horrible. Some Marshalls are the same way. It seems that the amp manufacturers in the high end market do a better job as of late but it still doesn't sound better then the natural amp gain one would get with driving the power tubes.
Pat, for the style of music you're playing I can see where you're coming from but even then I wouldn't dismiss pre amp gain outright. There are guys who can use it very effectively, but yes, powertube distortion is my preference as well. I'll go as far as playing with a clean sound before I use a pedal, if volume is an issue but sometimes I'll go for my old RealTube 901, set to very little gain but a higher output level. I'm convinced that I can get a similar (to my ear pleasing) preamp distortion out of almost any Fender or Marshall amp.
I believe the biggest problem is that many novices set the preamp gain to full since many amps SEEM to not sound very good with anything less. But a Boogie, Fender Rivera era BF or even Marshall can sound great with the preamp gain set to half or less. Deluxe II sounds fantastic for a MV amp.