The '59 Burst Replica that Jim built arrived tonight and after playing it for about three hours I feel compelled to write a report.
Jim's replica sustains forever and has a much, much wider range of tones. There are many tones that I've never heard from one Les Paul before. The low notes are tight and clear. It can get a woody, hollow midrange tone and a snappy highs. I played it thru a CAE OD-100, a blackface Pro Reverb, a Glaswerks SOD II, an Ampeg GU-12, a Marshall and a Quinn SDO. When played thru a overdriven amp the notes ring clear and cut thru. It still retains it's character. The difference is not subtile. It's a big difference! By comparison, the Gibson sounds dull and muddy. The David Allen Tom Cat Zebra PAF's are hotter than the Sheptone's and at first I thought I wouldn't like them. I realized that they just widen the palate. They still clean up nicely but can get much hotter. My favorite setting is both PUs on with the tones rolled back slightly. I'm able to get so much variety by blending the volumes against each other.
I started doing this on my conversions and offered to my customers as an option. IMOP I like the square plug instead of 3 dowels.
From so mahogany I got in the 80's.
I think I am in the camp with liking the dowels over the plug. Even if you match the grain, you still get the edges. Jmho as the rest looks great.
The last conversion I did had 5 end holes to fill.